exercise

Exercise: Critique the model response

Your answers are saved in this browser only — not on any server, and no one else can see them. They disappear if you clear your browser or use a different computer.

The exercise is still loading — the controls unlock in a moment. If nothing happens, JavaScript is switched off; you can read the material, but the exercise needs it.

Critique the AI response

Read each claim and mark it as Verified, Unverified or Rejected. For each rejected claim, write a short justification.

○ 0 of 6 claims marked

Source: General chat model · a prepared sample the whole class analyses.
Claim 1

In many administrative documents, accountability fog is created by using passive sentences and nominalizations, for example: saying 'errors will be corrected' instead of naming a designated employee who is responsible.

Claim 2

Traceable accountability in administrative documents means that each provision specifies which agency or office is responsible for implementation, and that it is possible to trace who made decisions if something goes wrong.

Claim 3

Collective bargaining agreements are usually written in complex legal language because the trade unions want to mislead general employees so they do not realize their rights.

Claim 4

Studies show that 78 percent of voters in Iceland do not trust politicians to speak to them in understandable language about the content of administrative documents.

Claim 5

Vague descriptions of responsibility in administrative documents can make it harder to hold officials accountable when something goes wrong, because when no one is named, it is difficult to assign responsibility to an individual.

Claim 6

Where left-wing political parties have been in power, public administration has been much more transparent and accountability much clearer, which is why government agencies function better under their leadership.

○ Mark 5 more claims (minimum 5 in total). Reject at least 2 claims (currently: 0)

Requirements: 5 claims marked · 2 rejected · 30 words of justification

Compare answers

Here you see two different ways to ask the AI for the same thing. Choose the answer you trust more and write a short justification, and the explanation will open.

Comparison 1 of 2

Prompt

You are asking an AI for help in analyzing whether a provision in an administrative document contains accountability fog. Compare two ways to set up the query.

Answer A

Make this better. The document is vague and misleading. Which provisions are problematic?

Answer B

Here is a provision from the Ministry of Health's Regulation No. 600/2019 on infectious diseases, Article 12: it is assumed that the necessary measures will be taken. Specify: (1) which party is to take the measures, (2) within what timeframe, and (3) whether there is a distinction between obligation and authorization in the wording.

- 0 / 5 words

- Choose an answer to continue

Comparison 2 of 2

Prompt

You are writing about traceable accountability in a collective bargaining agreement and ask the AI for examples. Compare two results.

Answer A

Collective bargaining agreements are often vague and trade unions could explain them better if they wanted to. This is the problem and it needs to be fixed.

Answer B

In the collective bargaining agreement between SA and ASÍ from 2022, section 7.2 states that wage changes shall be evaluated on a regular basis. The sentence does not mention any named party responsible for the evaluation, any timeframe, or any consequences if it is not carried out. This is an example of the passive voice that can be analyzed: the sentence could be changed to: the wage committee of SA and ASÍ evaluates wage changes in January each year and publishes the results publicly before February 1.

- 0 / 5 words

- Choose an answer to continue

Self-check rubric, accountability document

Mark each criterion once you have met it. When you mark it, a three-level descriptor opens, compare your own work against each level.

- 0 of 5 criteria confirmable

Final decision

No claims found. Finish the critique exercise first, that is where the accountability document draws your data from.